A nickel may be a bit much too thick - too much of an increase. I used a stainless steel flat washer that was in the range of 0.65mm to 0.75mm thick. Hard to say because I have a cheap caliper, it was under 1mm though.
NOTE: The amount of increase will be dependent upon what has been done to the engine.
Depending on your engine I'd say try a a thin flat washer or quarter since they are a little thiner than a nickel. You don't want the pressure too high.
If your engine is stock, not bored nor stroked, then there really is no need to increase the fuel pressure.